Once you read an electronic version of max stirners dialectical egoism. When not simply suppressed, it has been misrepresented or used as a. Apr 11, 2017 in this video, i cover the various kinds of egoism, as well as the conscious and unconscious egoist. Stirners main work, the ego and its own, literally known as the unique and its property, or, more colloquially, the individual and his property. A new interpretation examines stirners thought as a critique of modernity, by which he meant the domination of culture in stirners view, humanity is the supreme being of modernity and humanism is the prevailing legitimation of social and political domination. First, stirners opus magnum the ego and its own is one of the. Egoism is somehow akin to anarchism, but the differences overshadow the commonalities. This book is usually known as the ego and its own in english, but a more literal translation would be the unique individual and their property. He defends this interpretation in two influential introductions to stirnerian thought that he has written since 1995.
All the books on our website are divided into categories in order to make it easier for you to find the handbook you need. There are at least two implications of this contextfree method. Max sti rneits dialectical egoism a new interpretation max stirners dialectical egoism max stirners dialectical egoisl11 a new interpretation john f. Max stirners egoism jenkins 2009 the heythrop journal. Hence, some have used stirner s ideas to defend capitalism, while others have used them to argue for anarchosyndicalism. Stirner uses straightforward, even fairly simple language, filled with passion and sarcasm, to express ideas that are difficult, though more in the fact that very few. Stirner has been broadly understood as a proponent of both psychological egoism and ethical egoism, although the latter position can be disputed as there is no claim in stirners writing in which one ought to pursue ones own interest and further claiming any ought could be seen as a new fixed idea. Depending on the readers psychology, he or she can interpret it in drastically different ways. Instirnerwehavethephilosophicalfoundationforpoliticalliberty. Some commentators on max stirner have wanted to label him as a. A new interpretation, lanham, lexington books, 2010, p.
A new interpretation examines stirner s thought as a critique of modernity, by which he meant the domination of culture and politics by humanist ideology. Hence, some have used stirners ideas to defend capitalism, while others have used them to argue for anarchosyndicalism. Unless otherwise indicated all quotes are from stirners the ego and its own. A note on stirner, egoism, and anarchism by tracy harms.
This work appeared in december of 1844, and press copies were available even earlier, as moses hess had read and forwarded his copy to fredrich engels no later than early november of 1844. To some extent, stirner s work the ego and its own is like a rorschach test. A new interpretation i also included a chapter on stirner in my book after multiculturalism which discusses stirners view of race. To try to fit stirner into the contemporary mindset misses the point. A new interpretation pdf you will see how convenient it is. A note on stirner, egoism, and anarchism union of egoists. It presents a radically nominalist and individualist critique of christianity, nationalism, and traditional morality on one hand. Some commentators on max stirner have wanted to label him as a psychological egoist. Download pdf max stirner s dialectical egoism a new. Are there any reasonable accessible resources to aid my understanding out there. A new interpretation examines stirners thought as a critique of modernity, stirner was a student of hegel, and a critic of the young hegelians and the emerging forms of socialist and communist thought in the 1840s. The most thorough and coherent exploration of stirners thought available in english. In any case, this anarchodandys writing is invaluable to the serious student of egoism. Kinda need to know your philosophy history for this one.
Max stirner s main philosophical work was the ego and its own, also known as the ego and his. Stimers thought either endorses the anarchist notion that individuals cannot legitimately dominate others, or it endorses the archist idea that they can. A new interpretation examines stirner s thought as a critique of modernity, stirner was a student of hegel, and a critic of the young hegelians and the emerging forms of socialist and communist thought in the 1840s. In this video, i cover the various kinds of egoism, as well as the conscious and unconscious egoist. Paterson doesnt get anything related to dialectic, and heres proof. He offers an approach to human existence in which he depicts.
A new interpretation examines stirners thought as a critique of modernity, max stirner 18061856 is recognized in the history of political thought because of his egoist classic the ego and its own. First published in 1844, stirners the ego and his own 1 is regularly called the most radical book of all time, submitting a sweeping and penetrating indictment of society, morality, and even civilization itself. To some extent, stirners work the ego and its own is like a rorschach test. I also cover saint maxs thoughts on altruism, and whether or. Max stirner im currently reading the ego and its own, its quite obscure in places and im finding it difficult to locate any sort of useful secondary writings. Works written by or about max stirner at wikisource. In stirners view, humanity is the supreme being of modernity and humanism is the prevailing legitimation of social and political domination.
As one would expect of anarchists, egoists wholly reject alleged duties of citizenship, requirements of law, loyalties of patriotism and every other imposition which attends the state. Pdf slaughter, kevin a bible not borrowed from the neighbors. Welsh provides us with a superb distillation of the thought of. Max stirner s egoism and nihilism a thesis presented to the faculty of san diego state university in partial fulfilment of requirements for the degree of master of arts in philosophy by larry alan schiereck august, 1981, revised 1996 and 2015 sdsu thesis committee. Stirner s egoism is purely descriptive and must be understood in the dialectical context to which it refers. About the complicated relations between stirner and anarchists, see. This book interprets max stirners the ego and its own as a critique of modernity and traces the basic elements of his dialectical egoism through the writings of benjamin tucker, james l. The core of the max stirners individualist anarchism. In the ego and its own, stirner launches a radical antiauthoritarian and individualist critique of contemporary prussian society and modern western society as such. Welshs work max stirners dialectical egoism 2010 that a new vision.
A new interpretation examines stirners thought as a critique of modernity, by which he meant the. Hisinterestinthepractical development of egoism to the dissolution of the state and the union of free men. Pdf download max stirner s dialectical egoism a new. Depending on the reader s psychology, he or she can interpret it in drastically different ways. Max stirner 18061856 is recognized in the history of political thought because of his egoist classic the ego and its own. Newman is at his most inventive when he counteracts this impulse and asserts stirners egonot to be confused with the imaginary ego of postfreudian thoughtas an autonomous reality that. Japanese dadaist, anarchist, philosopher, monk welsh, john f.
Welshs interpretation considered not just the thought of stirner, but the. Translators preface stirners critics by max stirner szeliga feuerbach hess footnotes translators preface working on this translation has been a pleasurable challenge for me. Jan 10, 2017 in any case, this anarchodandys writing is invaluable to the serious student of egoism. Archists, anarchist and egoists in enemies of society. Stirner was a student of hegel, and a critic of the young hegelians and the emerging forms of socialist and communist thought in the 1840s. The final stage, egoism sees the now adult individual freed from all internal and external constraints, attaining individual autonomy. You can read online max stirner s dialectical egoism a new interpretation here in pdf, epub, mobi or docx formats. I have devoted a considerable amount of space to an analysis and. Ethical egoism ethical egoism ethical egoism what is universal ethical egoism. Larry schiereck, max stirners egoism and nihilism 19812015. With that in mind, we will summarise stirners main arguments and indicate why social anarchists have been, and should be, interested in his ideas. A thesis presented to the faculty of san diego state university in partial fulfilment of requirements for the degree of master of arts in philosophy.
The introduction says that it is mostly a critique or perhaps just an opinion of max stirner s egoism from a social anarchist point of view. The introduction says that it is mostly a critique or perhaps just an opinion of max stirners egoism from a social anarchist point of view. However, david leopold has claimed that there is not enough evidence in stirner s work to justify an interpretation in favour of psychological egoism. While dostoevsky and nietzsche must be acknowledged as the thinkers who plumbed the depths of nihilism most deeply, we can see the outlines of nihilismthough not fully developed as suchin an earlier work published by max stirner in 1844, the ego and his own. One is that stirners categorical or perennial philosophy can be studied apart from its time. Egoist anarchism or anarcho egoism, often shortened as simply egoism, is a school of anarchist thought that originated in the philosophy of max stirner, a 19thcentury existentialist philosopher whose name appears with familiar regularity in historically orientated surveys of anarchist thought as one of the earliest and best known exponents of individualist anarchism. A new interpretation examines stirners thought as a critique of modernity, by which he meant the domination of culture and politics by humanist ideology.
Johann kaspar schmidt 25 october 1806 26 june 1856, better known as max stirner, was a german philosopher who is often seen as one of the forerunners of nihilism, existentialism, psychoanalytic theory, postmodernism, and individualist anarchism. The philosophy of max stirner is credited as a major influence in the development of individualism, nihilism, existentialism, postmodernism and anarchism especially of egoist anarchism, individualist anarchism, postanarchism and postleft anarchy. He has written widely on max stirner and the young hegelians, including his book. Clark presents a sympathetic and useful social anarchist critique of his work in max stirners egoism. In stirners view humanity is the supreme being of modernity and humanism is the prevailing legitimation of social and political domination. I also cover saint max s thoughts on altruism, and whether or not he believed it to be real or not. A new interpretation i also included a chapter on stirner in my book after multiculturalism which discusses stirner s view of race. Egoist anarchism or anarchoegoism, often shortened as simply egoism, is a school of anarchist thought that originated in the philosophy of max stirner, a 19thcentury existentialist philosopher whose name appears with familiar regularity in historically orientated surveys of anarchist thought as one of the earliest and best known exponents of individualist anarchism. The relevance of max stirner to anarchocommunists filler. The politics of race and the dialectics of liberty both books are available in paperback. Stirner s egoism is an attempt to surpass the very idea of ought itself. Author of the article argues that in spite of a subjectivist nature of max stirners thought which is distinct from libertarianism, theres a strong intellectual affinity between anarchist wing of it and stirners conception.
1675 1160 1034 1237 1277 1255 1164 502 526 354 1029 523 1350 536 919 172 899 1039 1415 28 1529 28 1145 1079 797 491 721 509 535 774 142 242 1146